Evaluation of Public Participation in Environmental Assessment Policies: The Case of Slovenia and Canada

Mitja Durnik

doi:10.3986/AGS52203

Avtorji

Mitja Durnik

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3986/AGS52203

Ključne besede:

geografija, hidroenergetski razvoj, moč, prostor, udeležba javnosti, ekonomski razvoj skupnosti, proces vrednotenja okoljskih politik, Slovenija, Kanada

Povzetek

Pričujoča raziskava obravnava metodologijo udeležbe javnosti in politike ekonomskega razvoja skupnosti v procesu ocenjevanja okoljskih javnih politik. Poseben poudarek gre konceptom moči in prostora, ki skupaj omogočata marginalnim skupinam priložnost za vstop v javnopolitični proces. Obe nem pa je raziskovalni interes usmerjen v izboljšanje obstoječe metodologije participacije javnosti v kontekstu možne reintegracije ekspertnega in lokalnega sistema znanja. Na osnovi dveh študij primera (kanadskega projekta Wuskwatim in primera reke Soče v Sloveniji) so predstavljene razlike v oblikovanju koncepta vabljenega in zahtevanega/ustvarjenega javnopolitičnega prostora.

Prenosi

Podatki o prenosih še niso na voljo.

Literatura

Ackerlund, W. S. 2011: Exploring Public Participation Decision-Making at Superfund Sites: A Mental Models

Approach. Doctoral Dissertation. The University of Montana. Missoula MT.

Allen, J. 2009: Three Spaces of Power: Territory, Networks, plus a Topological twist in the Tale of Domination and Authority. Journal of Power 2-2. London. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17540290903064267

Alpe Adria Green. 2011: Nočemo ukinitve statusa reke Soče kot naravne vrednote. Internet: http://alpeadriagreen.wordpress.com/2011/09/05/podpiite-peticije-alpe-adria-green/ (3. 6. 2012).

Anko, B. 2011: Pripombe na predlog Novega energetskega zakona (private database by Blaž Komac) (21. 7. 2011).

Bachrach, P., Baratz, M. 1962: Two Faces of Power. American Political Science Review 56. Denton. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0003055406222561

Bachrach, P., Baratz, M. 1970: Power and poverty: theory and practice. New York, London, Toronto.

Brežan, U. 2011: Pripombe k predlogu Novega energetskega zakona (EZ-1). Internet: http://www.tolmin.si/datoteka/4a1590df1d5968d41b855005bb8b67bf (19. 4. 2012).

Canoe Fluviana Martisana. 2011: Dams’ Project in Soča Valley (private database by Blaž Komac) (21.7. 2011).

Civilna iniciativa Bovško polje. 2011: Posredovano stališče do novega energetskega zakona (private database by Blaž Komac) (20. 7. 2011).

Cipra. 2011: Zahteva po izločitvi 565. člena iz predloga Energetskega zakona (EZ-1) Internet: http://www.cipra.org/sl/CIPRA/cipra-slovenija/aktivnosti-v-teku/stalisce-cipre-slovenija-do-predloga-energetskega-zakona-ez-1-in-zahteva-po-izlocitvi-565-clena-tega-zakona/110722-ez-ukinitev-565-clena.pdf (3. 4. 2012).

Cox, K. R., Low, M., Robinson, J. 2008: Introduction. The Sage Handbook of Political Geography. Los Angeles; London; New Delhi; Singapore.

Dahl, R. 1958: A critique of the ruling elite model. American Political science Review 52-2. Denton.

Dahl, R. 1961: Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City. New Haven.

Daugbjerg, C. 1998: Policy Network under Pressure. Pollution Control, Policy Reform and the Power of Farmers, Aldershot.

Digeser, P. 1992: The Fourth Face of Power. Journal of Politics 54-4. Tucson. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2132105

Dondes. 2011: Soča in elektrarNE: usoda reke Soče in varstva narave v predlogu novega Energetskega zakona. Internet: http://www.naravnadediscina.org/?p=87 (4. 7. 2012).

Društvo ekologi brez meja. 2011: Spoštovani (private database by Blaž Komac).

Durnik, M. 2009: Canadian Public Policy and Poverty of Aboriginals. Doctoral Dissertation, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Ljubljana. Ljubljana.

Durnik, M. 2012: Between Dualism and Integration: Canadian Community Economic Development and its Implications for Future Development in the Slovenian Roma Community. Razprave in Gradivo - Treaties & Documents 67. Ljubljana.

Ek, R. 2011: Fire, Walk with Me: Towards a Geography of the Fourth Topology. 4th Nordic Geographers Meeting Roskilde.

Energy Manitoba. 2004: Wuswatim Archives. Internet:http://www.energymanitoba.org/wusk_archives/index.htm (7. 4. 2012).

Fitzpatrick, P. 2006: The Environmental Assessment Process – learning nexus: a Manitoba case study. Prairie Perspectives: Geographical Essays 9-1. Brandon.

Fitzpatrick, P., Sinclair A. J. 2009: Multi-jurisdictional environmental impact assessment: Canadian experiences. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 29. New York. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2009.01.004

Foth, M. 2011: Barriers to Aboriginal Participation in Environmental Assessment: A Case Study of the Wuskwatim Generating Station, Manitoba. Master Thesis, University of Manitoba. Winnipeg.

Gaventa, J. 2006: Finding the Spaces for Change: A Power Analysis. IDS Bulletin 37-6.

Golobič, M. 2011: Participativno prostorsko načrtovanje. III. Metode. Internet: http://uiraziskovalci.uirs.si/mojcag/partcipacija/ppn-3metode.pdf (7. 5. 2012).

Hessing, M., Howlett, M. 1997: Canadian Natural Resource and Environmental Policy: Political Economy and Public Policy. Vancouver.

Internet 1: http://www.hydro.mb.ca/projects/wuskwatim/overview.shtml?WT.mc_id=2625 (5. 3. 2012).

Internet 2: http://www.manitobaresearchallianceced.ca/cedall.html (5. 4. 2012).

Internet 3: http://www.wuskwatim.ca/empstats.html (4. 5. 2012).

Internet 4: http://www.ncncree.com/ncn/trainingjobs.html (4. 6. 2012).

Jones M., Jones R., Woods, M. 2008: An Introduction to Political Geography: Space, Place and Politics. London.

Karjalainen, T. P, Järvikoski T. 2010: Negotiating river ecosystems: Impact assessment and conflict mediation in the cases of hydro-power construction. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 30. New York. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2010.04.004.

Kempton, K. 2004: Oral Submission for Main Hearing, Presentation on CEC Hearings Wuskwatim Projects, Pimicamak Cree Nation. Internet: http://energymanitoba.org/presenters.htm (5. 8. 2008).

Keršič Svetel, M. 2011: Oblast brez vrednot. Internet: http://www.naravnadediscina.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/vlada-brez-vrednot_ksvetel_vecer.pdf (23. 3. 2012).

Kobliski, K. 2004: CEC Presentation Notes: Winnipeg. Displaced Residents of South Indian Lake, Justice Seekers of Nelson House, CEC Hearings Wuskwatim Projects. Internet: http://energymanitoba.org/presenters.htm (5. 8. 2011).

Komac, B. 2009: Social memory and geographical memory of natural disasters. Acta geographica Slovenica 49-1. Ljubljana. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3986/AGS49107

Komac, B. 2011: Pripombe na predlog Energetskega zakona (Blaž Komac in sopodpisniki) (private archive by Blaž Komac).

Loxley, J. 2007: Elements of a Theory of Community Economic Development, Transforming or Reforming Capitalism – Towards a Theory of Community Economic Development. Halifax.

Loxley, J. 2010: Aboriginal, Northern, and Community Economic Development: Papers and Retrospectives. Winnipeg.

Lukes, S.1974: Power: A Radical View. Basingstoke, London.

Lukes, S. 2005: Power: A Radical View (2nd ed.). Basingstoke.

Manitoba Research Alliance. 2006: Accessing the Impact of the New Economy. Internet: http://www.manitobaresearchallianceced.ca/Documents/Thematic_Summaries/AssessingtheImpactsoftheNewEconomy-WEB.pdf (4. 5. 2012).

Martin, T. and Hoffman, M. S. (eds.). 2008: Power Struggles: Hydro Development and First Nations in Manitoba and Quebec. Winnipeg.

Mendel, M. 2010: Empowerment: From Noise to Voice. Universitas Forum: International Journal on Human Development and International Cooperation 2-1. Rome. Ministrstvo za gospodarstvo. 2011: The New Proposed Energy Law (Predlog novega Energetskega zakona). Internet: http://www.mzip.gov.si/fileadmin/mzip.gov.si/pageuploads/Energetika/Predlogi_predpisov/EZ_1_v_okt_2011.pdf (7. 2. 2012).

Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation. 2012: Internet: http://www.ncncree.com/ncn/wuskwatimproject.html (3. 2. 2012).

Omladič, L. 2011: Za zgornjo Sočo vlada odpravlja okoljske omejitve. Internet: http://blog.kvarkadabra.net/2011/07/za-zgornjo-soco-vlada-odpravlja.html (10. 6. 2011).

Ostan, C. 2011: Mnenje in pripombe mag. Cecilije Ostan, direktorice LTO Bovec, na predlog Energetskega zakona. Internet: http://www.posocje.net/novica/2011/07/mnenje-in-pripombe-mag-cecilije-ostan-direktorice-lto-bovec-na-predlog-energetskega-z (25. 3. 2012).

Pinho P., Rodrigo M., Monterroso A. 2007: The quality of Portuguese Environmental Impact Studies: The case of small hydropower projects. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 27. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2006.10.005.

Planinska zveza Slovenije. 2011: Planinska zveza Slovenije nasprotuje ponovnemu poskusu razvrednotenja reke Soče. Internet: http://www.cipra.org/sl/CIPRA/cipra-slovenija/aktivnosti-v-teku/stalisce-cipre-slovenija-do-predloga-energetskega-zakona-ez-1-in-zahteva-po-izlocitvi-565-clena-tega-zakona/pzs-sporocilo-za-javnost.pdf (10. 6. 2012).

Ribiška družina Tolmin. 2011: Spoštovani (private database by Blaž Komac) (20. 7. 2011).

Ribiška zveza Slovenije. 2011: Ribiška zveza Slovenije nasprotuje nadaljnji energetski izrabi Soče in njenih pritokov. Internet: http://www.carpinslovenia.com/download/Soca-predlog%20energetskega%20zakona.pdf (3. 6. 2012).

Rousseau, J. 2000: The New Political Scales of Citizenship in a Global Era: The Politics of Hydroelectric Development in the James Bay Region. Doctoral Dissertation, Carleton University. Ottawa.

Sheldrick, B. 2007: Community Economic Development: Governance and State-Civil society Relations, Transforming or Reforming Capitalism: Towards a Theory of Community Economic Development. Halifax.

Shragge, E. 2003: Activism and Social Change: Lessons for Community and Local Organizing. Toronto.

Sinclair A. J., Diduck A., Fitzpatrick, P. 2008: Conceptualizing learning for sustainability through environmental assessment: critical reflections on 15 years of research. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 28. New York. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2007.11.001

Slovenska turistična organizacija. 2011: Pripombe na Predlog Novega Energetskega zakona EZ-1 (private database by Blaž Komac) (8. 8. 2011).

Slovenski P.E.N. center. 2011: Okrogla miza o usodi Soče in Posočja (private database by Blaž Komac) (29.8.2011).

Söderström, O., Geertman S. 2012: Loose Threads: The Translocal Making of Public Space Policy in Hanoi. WPS 176. Singapore.

Thórhallsdóttir, T. E. 2006: Environment and energy in Iceland: A comparative analysis of values and impacts. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 27. New York. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2006.12.004

The Law Establishing the Protected Area of the River Soča and its Tributaries (Zakon o določitvi zavarovanega območja za reko Sočo s pritoki). Uradni list Socialistične Republike Slovenije 7/1976. Ljubljana.

The Manitoba Research Alliance on Community Economic Development in the New Economy. 2011: Internet: http://www.manitobaresearchallianceced.ca/cedall.html (4. 5. 2012). The Nature Conservation Act (Zakon o ohranjanju narave); Uradni list RS 56/99, 31/00, 119/02, 22/03, 41/04, 96/04 – UPB). Ljubljana.

Triglavski narodni park. 2011: Stališče TNP k predlogu Energetskega zakona (EZ-1): TNP predlagatelja EZ-1 poziva, da se 565. člen umakne iz zakona. Internet:http://www.tnp.si/news/more/stalishche_tnp_k_predlogu_energetskega_zakona_ez-1/ (3. 6. 2012).

Zavod LTO Sotočje. 2011: Spoštovani. Internet: http://www.cipra.org/sl/CIPRA/cipra-slovenija/aktivnosti-v-teku/stalisce-cipre-slovenija-do-predloga-energetskega-zakona-ez-1-in-zahteva-po-izlocitvi-565-clena-tega-zakona/lto-pripombe.pdf (13. 5. 2012).

Zavod Republike Slovenije zavarstvo narave. 2011: Predlog Energetskega zakona posega v zavarovanje reke Soče. Internet: http://www.cipra.org/sl/CIPRA/cipra-slovenija/aktivnosti-v-teku/stalisce-cipre-slovenija-do-predloga-energetskega-zakona-ez-1-in-zahteva-po-izlocitvi-565-clena-tega-zakona/zrsvn_soca_ez_18_7_2011.pdf (7. 4. 2012).

Zorn M., Komac, B. 2011: Damage caused by natural disasters in Slovenia and globally between 1995 and 2010. Acta geographica Slovenica, 51-1. Ljubljana. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3986/AGS51101