Disjecta Membra: Althusser’s Aesthetics Reconsidered
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.3986/fv.41.1.01Keywords:
aesthetics, art, ideology, science, marxism, materialism, painting, theaterAbstract
This essay takes a synthetic and critical approach to the scattered pieces of art criticism and aesthetic theory authored by Louis Althusser. Connecting these texts to his larger philosophical and political project, we argue that these reflections make an independent contribution to its worth and that they offer different perspectives on lingering theoretical problems. We piece together the insights that form the core of the Althusserian approach to aesthetics and show how these are formulated (in connection with the work of Pierre Macherey as well as the dominant controversies of the time) and trace how their formulations take shape in relation to the work of different authors and artists. In addition to helping us better understand his overall project, Althusser’s aesthetic theory is, we argue, a powerful and original contribution to Marxist aesthetics. Specifically, it points us to the idea that we need to take aesthetic production seriously as a practice with its own specificity – one that has its own logics of determination, rituals of production, circulation, and consumption, one that commands effects that need to be theorized on their own terms.
Downloads
References
References
Albrecht, Thomas, “Donner à voir l’idéologie: Althusser and Aesthetic Ideology”, Bulletin de La Société Americaine de Philosophie de Langue Française 14 (Fall 2004), No. 2
Althusser, Louis, “A Conversation on Literary History”, in History and Imperialism, Polity Press, Cambridge, UK and Medford, MA 2020
— “A Letter on Art in Reply to André Daspre”, in Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays, translated by Ben Brewster, Monthly Review Press, New York 2001
— “A Young Cuban Painter Before Surrealism: Álvarez Ríos (1962)”, ARTMargins 6 (June 2017), No. 2
— “Book on Imperialism”, in History and Imperialism, Polity Press, Cambridge, UK and Medford, MA 2020
— “Cremonini, Painter of the Abstract”, in Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays, trans. Ben Brewster, Monthly Review Press, New York 2001
— “Entretien avec Giorgio Fanti”, April 1980, Fonds Althusser 20ALT/46/36, Institut Mémoires de l’Édition Contemporaine
— For Marx, Allen Lane, London 1969
— “‘Lam (1977)’”, trans. Alberto Toscano, ARTMargins 6 (2017), No. 2
— “Letter to the Central Committee of the PCF, 18 March 1966”, Historical Materialism 15, (2007), No. 2
— Lettres à Franca: 1961-1973, ed. François Matheron and Yann Moulier Boutang, Édition posthume d’oeuvres de Louis Althusser 6, Stock IMEC, Paris 1998
— “On the Twenty-Second Congress of the French Communist Party”, New Left Review 1 (August 1977), No. 104
— “Marx in His Limits”, in Philosophy of the Encounter: Later Writings, 1978–87, ed. Francois Matheron, trans. G.M. Goshgarian, Verso, London and New York 2006
— “Marxism Today”, in Philosophy and the Spontaneous Philosophy of the Scientists & Other Essays, ed. Gregory Elliott, Verso, London and New York 1990
— “Perchè il teatro : Conferenza dibatto promossa dal ‘Teatro Minimo’ di Forli deI Professore Louis Althusser”, La Provincia di Forli, January 8, 1964, sec. Supplemento al. n/ 1
— Philosophy for Non-Philosophers, trans. G. M Goshgarian. Bloomsbury, New York 2017
— “Some Questions Concerning the Crisis of Marxist Theory and of the International Communist Movement”, Historical Materialism 23 (March 25, 2015), No. 1
— “Sur Lucio Fanti (mars 1977)”, in Écrits philosophiques et politiques, Tome II, ed. François Matheron, Stock IMEC, Paris 1995
— The Future Lasts Forever: A Memoir, ed. Olivier Corpet and Yann Moulier-Boutang, tran. Richard Veasey, New Press, New York 1995
— “The International of Decent Feelings”, in The Spectre of Hegel: Early Writings, ed. François Matheron, trans. G. M Goshgarian, Verso, London and New York 1997
— “The ‘Piccolo Teatro’: Bertolazzi and Brecht (1962)”, in For Marx, London, Allen Lane, 1969
— “Three Notes on the Theory of Discourses”, in The Humanist Controversy and Other Writings, 1966-67, ed. François Matheron, Verso, London and New York 2003
— “The Crisis of Marxism”, Marxism Today (July 1978)
Althusser, Louis, and Balibar, Etienne, Reading “Capital”, trans. Ben Brewster, NLB, London 1970
Balibar, Étienne, “Althusser’s Dramaturgy and the Critique of Ideology”, Differences 26 (November 1, 2015), No. 3
— “Althusser’s Object”, trans. Margaret Cohen and Bruce Robbins. Social Text (July 1, 1994), No. 39
Bargu, Banu, “Althusser’s Materialist Theater: Ideology and Its Aporias” Differences 26 (November 1, 2015), No. 3
— “In the Theater of Politics: Althusser’s Aleatory Materialism and Aesthetics”, Diacritics 40 (2012), No. 3
Bellet, Harry, “Pierre Gaudibert, écrivain et critique d’art”, Le Monde.fr. (January 23, 2006)
Brandt, Per, “Fiction et Philosophie. Les Notes d’Althusser Sur Un Théâtre Matérialiste 1”, Revue Romane 1 (January 1, 1977)
Carmichael, Thomas, “Structure and Conjuncture Literary Study and the Return to Althusser”, E-Rea. Revue Électronique d’études Sur Le Monde Anglophone (June 15, 2005), No. 3.1
Carney, Sean, Brecht and Critical Theory: Dialectics and Contemporary Aesthetics, Routledge, Taylor and Francis, London and New York 2012
Cavazzini, Andrea, Scienze, epistemologia, società: la lezione di Louis Althusser: Venezia, 29-30-31 ottobre 2008: atti del convegno, Mimesis, Milano 2009
Daspre, André, and Louis Althusser, “Deux Lettres Sur La Connaissance de l’art”, La Nouvelle Critique (April 1966), No. 175
Demaitre, Edmund, “In Search of Humanism Marxism-Leninism”, Problems of Communism 14 (1965), No. 5
Doy, Gen, “Materializing Art History”, Art History (1998)
Eldridge, Richard, “Althusser and Ideological Criticism of the Arts”, in Explanation and Value in the Arts, ed. Salim Kemal and Ivan Gaskell, 1st ed., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1993
Erjavec, Aleš, “Art and Criticism”, Filozofski Vestnik 40 (2019), No. 3
Fielbaum, Alejandro, “Materialismo y distancia. Brecht en Althusser”, in Actas del Coloquio Internacional Althusser hoy: estrategia y materialismo, ed. Marcelo Starcenbaum, Natalia Romé, Marcelo Rodríguez Arriagada, and Pedro Karczmarczyk, Universidad de la Plata, Santiago, Chile 2020
Garo, Isabelle, “The Impossible Break: Ideology in Movement between Philosophy and Politics”, in Encountering Althusser: Politics and Materialism in Contemporary Radical Thought, Bloomsbury Academic, New York 2013
Gauvin, Didier, “Un intellectuel communiste illégitime: Roger Garaudy”, PhD Thesis, Université Grenoble Alpes 2016
Goshgarian, G. M, “Introduction to The Humanist Controversy and Other Writings, 1966-67”, in The Humanist Controversy and Other Writings, 1966–67, Verso, London and New York 2003
— “Note on the Text”, in Louis Althusser, History and Imperialism, Polity Press, Cambridge, UK and Medford, MA 2020
IMEC, “Louis Althusser (1918-1990), Bibliothèque Personnelle : Monographies”, Institut Mémoires de l’Édition Contemporaine, March 2018
Kowsar, Mohammad, “Althusser on Theatre”, Theatre Journal 35 (1983), No. 4
Lacan, Jacques, Ecrits: The First Complete Edition in English, Norton, New York 2006
Lefebvre, Henri, Dialectical Materialism, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis 2009
Lewis, William S., “Althusser’s Scientism and Aleatory Materialism”, Décalages 2, (January 1, 2016), No. 1
— “‘Editorial Introduction to Louis Althusser’s “Letter to the Central Committee of the PCF, 18 March, 1966”’”, Historical Materialism 15 (2007), No. 2
— “Knowledge versus ‘Knowledge’: Louis Althusser on the Autonomy of Science and Philosophy from Ideology”, Rethinking Marxism 17 (2005), No. 3
Loubet del Bayle, Jean-Louis, “Le mouvement personnaliste français des années 1930 et sa postérité”, Politique et Sociétés 17 (1998), No. 1–2
Macherey, Pierre, A Theory of Literary Production, trans. Geoffrey Wall, Routledge, London 2006
— “Althusser and the Concept of the Spontaneous Philosophy of Scientists”, trans. Robin Mackay, Parrhesia 6 (2009)
Macherey, Pierre, and Étienne Balibar, “Literature as an Ideological Form: Some Marxist Propositions”, trans. John Whitehead Mcleod and Ann Wordsworth, Oxford Literary Review 3 (1978), No. 1
Matheron, François, “Louis Althusser, or the Impure Purity of the Concept”, Critical Companion to Contemporary Marxism, Leiden and Boston 2004
Matonti, Frédérique, Intellectuels Communistes: Essai Sur l’obéissance Politique : “La Nouvelle Critique” (1967-1980), Editions la Découverte, Paris 2005
Montag, Warren, Louis Althusser, Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire and New York 2003
— “Spinoza’s Counter-Aesthetics”, Intellectual History Review 30 (2020), No. 3
Montag, Warren, and Louis Althusser, “On Brecht and Marx (1968)”, in Louis Althusser, trans. Max Statkiewicz, Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire and New York 2003
Moulier-Boutang, Yann, “L’interdit Biographique et l’autorisation de l’oeuvre”, Futur Antérieur/L’Harmattan. Numéro Spécial : Lire Althusser aujourd’hui (April 1997)
Osborne, Harold, “The Doctrine of Reflection in Soviet Aesthetics”, The British Journal of Aesthetics 23 (March 1, 1983), No. 3
Padilla, Maria Cecilia, and Roberto Bey, Facundo, “La Ciencia Es Ciencia de La Ideología En Louis Althusser”, Desafios (January 28, 2016), No. 1
Peden, Knox, Spinoza Contra Phenomenology: French Rationalism from Cavaillès to Deleuze, Stanford University Press, Stanford 2014
Pfeifer, Geoff, “On Althusser on Science, Ideology, and the New, or Why We Should Continue to Read ‘Reading Capital’”, Crisis & Critique, Reading Capital and For Marx: 50 Years Later, 2 (January 1, 2015), No. 2
Pic, Roger, “[El Nost Milan, Texte de Carlo Bertolazzi e Photographies / Roger Pic]”, Image, Gallica, 1962, available at: https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b84200619.
Pippa, Stefano, “A Heap of Splinters On the Floor”, SoftPower 7, (June 2020), No. 1
Poirot-Delpech, Bertrand, “‘El nost Milan’, de Bertolazzi par le Piccolo Teatro de Milan”, Le Monde.fr, June 15, 1962
Read, Malcolm K, “Towards a Notion of the Ideological Unconscious: Marx, Althusser, Juan Carlos Rodríguez”, Historical Materialism 25 (2017), No. 4
Seguín, Bécquer, “Mute Cries: Louis Althusser Between Roberto Álvarez Ríos and Wifredo Lam”, ARTMargins 6 (June 2017), No. 2
Sibertin-Blanc, Guillaume, Chapitre II. De la théorie du théâtre à la scène de la théorie : réflexions sur « Le “Piccolo”, Bertolazzi et Brecht » d’Althusser. Le Moment philosophique des années 1960 en France, Presses Universitaires de France, Paris 2011
Skees, Murray W, “Kant, Adorno and the ‘Work’ of Art”, Philosophy & Social Criticism 37 (October 2011), No. 8
Sotiris, Panagiotis, A Philosophy for Communism: Rethinking Althusser. A Philosophy for Communism, Brill, Leiden and Boston 2020
Wilson, Sarah, The Visual World of French Theory: Figurations, Yale University Press, New Haven, CT 2010
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Authors guarantee that the work is their own original creation and does not infringe any statutory or common-law copyright or any proprietary right of any third party. In case of claims by third parties, authors commit their self to defend the interests of the publisher, and shall cover any potential costs.
More in: Submission chapter
