Newton, the Inaccessible Essence of Bodies, Theological Voluntarism and the Laws of Nature

  • Matjaž Vesel Znanstvenoraziskovalni center Slovenske akademije znanosti in umetnosti, Filozofski inštitut
Keywords: Newton, inaccessible nature of the body, theological voluntarism, laws of nature

Abstract

Isaac Newton affirms on several occasions that human understanding cannot reach the essence of bodies. The article seeks to answer the question of why we cannot reach their essence either through our reflection or our senses, which confines our cognition to their appearances. I argue that the answer to this problem lies in Newton’s theological voluntarism, which he fully developed for the first time and explicitly in relation to the problem of the nature of bodies in his manuscript De gravitatione. Newton’s God could create beings (entia) similar to bodies, which display all their actions and exhibit all their phenomena, and yet they would not be bodies in their essential and metaphysical constitution. Newton’s theological voluntarism has other important epistemological consequences, such as God’s ability to freely change the laws of nature according to his will.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Ariew, Roger, »Descartes’s Fable and Scientific Methodology«, Archives internationales
d’histoire des sciences 55 (2005), str. 127–138
— »The New Matter Theory and its Epistemology: Descartes (and Late Scholastics) on
Hypotheses and Moral Certainty«, v Jalobeanu in Anstey (ur.), Vanishing Matter and
the Laws of Nature, str. 31–46
Birch, Thomas, The History of the Royal Society, 3 zv., A. Millar in the Strand, London 1757
Cohen, Bernard, »The Review of the First Edition of Newton’s Principia in the Acta
Eruditorum, with Notes on the other Reviews«, v P. M. Harman in Alan Shapiro (ur.),
The Investigation of Difficult Things: Essays on Newton and the History of the Exact
Sciences in Honour of D. T. Whiteside, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1992,
str. 323–354
Curley, Edwin, »Certainty: Psychological, Moral, and Metaphysical«, v Stephen Voss
(ur.), Essays on the Philosophy and Science of René Descartes, Oxford University
Press, Oxford 1993, str. 11–30
Damerow, Peter, »Space and Matter in Early Modern Science: The Impenetrability of
Matter«, v Matthias Schemmel (ur.), Spatial Thinking and External Representation:
Towards a Historical Epistemology of Space, Max Planck Institute for the History of
Science, Berlin 2016, str. 175–190
Davis, Edward, »Newton’s Rejection of the ‘Newtonian World View’: The Role of Divine
Will in Newton’s Natural Philosophy«, Science and Christian Belief 3 (1/1991), str.
103–117
Dempsey, Liam, »Newtonian Idealism: Matter, Perception, and the Divine Will«, The
Southern Journal of Philosophy 52 (1/2014), str. 86–112
Descartes, René, Principia philosophiae, v Oeuvres de Descartes, VIII-1, ur. C. Adam in P.
Tannery, Cerf, Pariz 1905, str. 1–348
— Principi filozofije, drugi del, 1–44, prev. Matej Hriberšek, v Filozofski vestnik 39 (1/2018),
str. 35–65
Dobbs, Betty Jo Teeter, The Janus Faces of Genius: The Role of Alchemy in Newton’s
Thought, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1991
Ducheyne, Steffen, The Main Business of Philosophy: Isaac Newton’s Natural-Philosophical
Methodology, Springer, Dordrecht 2012
Gabbey, Alan, »The Term materia in Newton and in the Newtonian Tradition«, v Delfina
Giovannozzi in Marco Veneziani (ur.), Materia: Atti del XIII colloquio internazionale
del lessico intellettuale Europeo, Leo S. Olschki, Firence 2011, str. 423–445
Garber, Daniel, John Henry, Lynn Joy in Alan Gabbey, »New Doctrines of Body and its
Powers, Place and Space«, v Daniel Garber in Michael Ayers (ur.), The Cambridge
History of Seventeenth Century Philosophy, 1. zv., Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge 1998, str. 553–623
Guerlac, Henry, »Theological Voluntarism and Biological Analogies in Newton’s Physical
Thought«, Journal of the History of Ideas 44 (1983), str. 219–229
Hall, Rupert, in Marie Boas Hall (ur. in prev.), Unpublished Scientific Papers of Isaac
Newton: A Selection from the Portsmouth Collection in the University Library,
Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1962
Harrison, Peter, »Was Newton a Voluntarist?«, v James Force in Sarah Hutton (ur.),
Newton and Newtonianism, Kluwer, Dordrecht 2004, str. 39–63
— »Voluntarism and the Origins of Modern Science: A Reply to John Henry«, History of
Science 47 (2009), str. 223–231
Heimann, P. M., »Voluntarism and Immanence: Conceptions of Nature in Eighteenth-
Century Thought«, Journal of the History of Ideas 39 (2/1978), str. 271–283
Henry, John, »Voluntarism and Early Modern Science: A Response to Peter Harrison«,
History of Science 40 (2002), str. 63–89
Iliffe, Rob, »‘That Puzleing Problem’: Isaac Newton and the Political Physiology of Self«,
Medical History 39 (1995), str. 433–458
— The Priest of Nature: The Religious Worlds of Isaac Newton, Oxford University Press,
Oxford 2017
Jalobeanu, Dana, »Space, Bodies and Geometry: Some Sources of Newton’s Metaphysics«,
Zeitsprünge: Forschungen zur frühen Neuzeit 11 (1–2/2007), str. 81–113
— »The Cartesians of the Royal Society: The Debate over Collisions and the Nature of
Body (1668–1670)«, v Jalobeanu in Anstey (ur.), Vanishing Matter and the Laws of
Nature, str. 103–129
— »The Nature of Body«, v Anstey (ur.), The Oxford Handbook of British Philosophy in the
Seventeenth Century, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2013, str. 213–239
Jalobeanu, Dana, in Peter Anstey (ur.), Vanishing Matter and the Laws of Nature: Descartes
and Beyond, Routledge, London 2011
Koyré, Alexandre, Newtonian Studies, Chapman in Hall, London 1965
Leibniz, Gottfried, Anti-barbarus physicus, v isti, Die philosophischen Schriften, 7. zv., ur.
C. I. Gerhardt, Berlin 1890, str. 337–344
McGuire, James, »Newton on Place, Time and God: An Unpublished Source«, British
Journal for the History of Science 11 (1978), str. 114–129
— »Body and Void and Newton‘s De Mundi Systemate: Some New Sources«, v isti,
Tradition and Innovation: Newton‘s Metaphysics of Nature, Kluwer, Dordrecht 1995,
str. 103–150
Newton, Isaac, Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica, ur. Alexandre Koyré in I.
Bernard Cohen s pomočjo Anne Whitman, tretja izdaja Principia iz leta 1726 z različicami
besedila iz prvih dveh izdaj, dva zvezka s kontinuirano paginacijo, Harvard
University Press, Cambridge 1972
— Opticks: or, a Treatise of the Reflexions, Refractions, Inflexions and Colours of Light,
William Innys, London 1730
— Philosophical Writings, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2014.
— Izbrani spisi I, prev. Matej Hriberšek in Valerija Vendramin, Založba ZRC, Ljubljana
2020
— »Hipoteza o svetlobi«, prev. Valerija Vendramin, v Newton, Izbrani spisi I, str. 63–79
— »De gravitatione/O težkosti«, prev. Matej Hriberšek in Matjaž Vesel, v Newton, Izbrani
spisi I, str. 81–143
— Matematični principi filozofije narave: kratek izbor, prev. Matej Hriberšek,
Filozofski
vestnik 41 (3/2020), str. 7–77
— CUL Add. Ms. 3965 (rokopisi povezani s Principia)
— Dibner NMAHRB Ms. 1031 B (sinopsis prvih branj alkemijskih del).
— Keynes Ms. 3 (Irenicum, or Ecclesiastical Polyty tending to Peace).
— Yahuda Ms. 21 (Exposition of 2 Kings, 17: 15–16)
Oakley, Francis, »Christian Theology and the Newtonian Science: The Rise of the Concept
of Laws of Nature«, Church History 30 (1961), str. 433–457
Osler, Margaret, Divine Will and the Mechanical Philosophy: Gassendi and Descartes
on Contingency and Necessity in the Created World, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge 1994
Tamny, Martin, »Newton, Creation, and Perception«, Isis 70 (1/1979), str. 48–58
Vesel, Matjaž, »Newtonova zgodnja dela: narava svetlobe in barv, teorija materije in filozofski
obračun z Descartesom«, v Isaac Newton, Izbrani spisi I, str. 167–230
Published
2020-12-31
How to Cite
1.
Vesel M. Newton, the Inaccessible Essence of Bodies, Theological Voluntarism and the Laws of Nature. FV [Internet]. 2020Dec.31 [cited 2021Nov.30];41(3). Available from: https://ojs.zrc-sazu.si/filozofski-vestnik/article/view/9874